Bought these for my husband, he is outdoor a lot. He says they are comfortable but slightly large for him. He typically wears a 9.5, so I ordered a 10. I was thinking the size 9 would have been too little, maybe not. He doesn't want the hassle of sending them back and getting a size that may not fit any better. He may change his mind but only time will tell.
I gave it 4 stars because I am not sure about the feel and texture of the soles. They seem a bit heavy hitting when I walk on a solid surface. So, I am not really sure. I wore these once...but will see.
I wear them around the house and they are very comfortable. I like the fact that your socks and feet don't get wet if you go outside in the wet grass. Also like that they are washable although I haven't washed them yet. I have never thought Crocs were attractive