My husband and I get out in the woods almost every day, even during hunting seasons. We wanted a jacket that was orange, wind proof, breathable, and didn’t break the bank. These worked perfect for us. This spring, we had several days that were very windy but sunny. These jackets helped keep our cores warm. Although I don’t think they are water proof, we’ve gotten caught in a few light showers and they’ve kept us dry.
Pros- Nice material and workmanship, just the right amount of insulation for mid-late season bird hunting
The bad- Even after going up a size as recommended here, the shoulders and sleeves are way to restrictive. I couldn't even layer a long sleeve t-shirt under it without it bunching up. Raising my arms as if shouldering a gun lifted the entire jacket to my midriff. I bought an XL, and I am 5'11, 205 with a pretty average build.
I really wanted to like this, but I ended up returning it. The fit would have really annoyed me over time.