{"reviews":[{"id":6874975,"locale":"en_US","rating":1,"title":"Nice shoe","text":"One of my biggest needs was for a shoe that could accommodate custom orthotics and this shoe did the trick. The shoe is light weight and not bulky or with a thick sole. The shoe color is nice, the materials feel of good quality and appear to be well made.","textLength":255,"csFlag":false,"inappropriateFlag":false,"reviewedFlag":false,"autoModerated":false,"published":true,"incentivized":false,"upVotes":0,"downVotes":0,"orderId":null,"dimensions":[],"responses":[],"tags":[],"media":{"photo":[],"video":[],"audio":[]},"user":{"nickName":"Donald","firstName":null,"lastName":null,"emailAddress":null,"externalId":null,"city":null,"state":null,"country":null,"ageRange":null,"badge":null,"shopperProfiles":[]},"reviewedDate":null,"purchaseDate":null,"dateCreated":"2025-07-07T00:00:00-04:00","customData":[],"incentiveType":null,"campaign":null,"deviceFingerprint":null,"topics":[],"syndication":{"sourceName":"Johnston Murphy","siteUrl":"https://www.johnstonmurphy.com","logoUrl":"https://images.turnto.com/site/syndicationlogos/4378_LH48.png"},"catalogItems":[{"sku":"12128-2502641","title":"Men's Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Plain Toe Dress Shoes","url":"https://www.scheels.com/p/12128-2502641","category":"oxfords-lace-ups","reviewCount":895,"ratingCount":895,"averageRating":4.6,"ratingBreakdown":{"1":34,"2":24,"3":40,"4":107,"5":690},"active":true,"attributes":[]}]},{"id":6861983,"locale":"en_US","rating":5,"title":"Looks great, feels great","text":"Needed a new pair of business casual shoes for a work trip to London and liked the way these looked. Knew I was going to be doing a lot of walking so rolled the dice that the breaking period would be short and these were super comfortable right out of the box.","textLength":260,"csFlag":false,"inappropriateFlag":false,"reviewedFlag":false,"autoModerated":false,"published":true,"incentivized":false,"upVotes":0,"downVotes":0,"orderId":null,"dimensions":[],"responses":[],"tags":[],"media":{"photo":[],"video":[],"audio":[]},"user":{"nickName":"Bradley","firstName":null,"lastName":null,"emailAddress":null,"externalId":null,"city":null,"state":null,"country":null,"ageRange":null,"badge":null,"shopperProfiles":[]},"reviewedDate":null,"purchaseDate":null,"dateCreated":"2025-06-13T00:00:00-04:00","customData":[],"incentiveType":null,"campaign":null,"deviceFingerprint":null,"topics":[],"syndication":{"sourceName":"Johnston Murphy","siteUrl":"https://www.johnstonmurphy.com","logoUrl":"https://images.turnto.com/site/syndicationlogos/4378_LH48.png"},"catalogItems":[{"sku":"12128-2502641","title":"Men's Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Plain Toe Dress Shoes","url":"https://www.scheels.com/p/12128-2502641","category":"oxfords-lace-ups","reviewCount":895,"ratingCount":895,"averageRating":4.6,"ratingBreakdown":{"1":34,"2":24,"3":40,"4":107,"5":690},"active":true,"attributes":[]}]},{"id":6948492,"locale":"en_US","rating":1,"title":"Terrible quality","text":"Terrible quality! Bought these for my son based on high reviews. He sent photos after 2 weeks of gentle wear to the office and back - shoes already separating from soles along all four sides, and heel of the shoe he uses for clutch is worn down. 10 days of wear? Total garbage. Going back to Simonen- Beckett.","textLength":309,"csFlag":false,"inappropriateFlag":false,"reviewedFlag":false,"autoModerated":false,"published":true,"incentivized":false,"upVotes":0,"downVotes":0,"orderId":null,"dimensions":[],"responses":[],"tags":[],"media":{"photo":[],"video":[],"audio":[]},"user":{"nickName":"Smape","firstName":null,"lastName":null,"emailAddress":null,"externalId":null,"city":null,"state":null,"country":null,"ageRange":null,"badge":null,"shopperProfiles":[]},"reviewedDate":null,"purchaseDate":null,"dateCreated":"2025-06-12T00:00:00-04:00","customData":[],"incentiveType":null,"campaign":null,"deviceFingerprint":null,"topics":[],"syndication":{"sourceName":"Johnston Murphy","siteUrl":"https://www.johnstonmurphy.com","logoUrl":"https://images.turnto.com/site/syndicationlogos/4378_LH48.png"},"catalogItems":[{"sku":"12128-2502641","title":"Men's Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Plain Toe Dress Shoes","url":"https://www.scheels.com/p/12128-2502641","category":"oxfords-lace-ups","reviewCount":895,"ratingCount":895,"averageRating":4.6,"ratingBreakdown":{"1":34,"2":24,"3":40,"4":107,"5":690},"active":true,"attributes":[]}]},{"id":6861981,"locale":"en_US","rating":5,"title":"Very nice shoes","text":"These shoes are great. Very comfortable and look terrific even though I have big wide feet.","textLength":91,"csFlag":false,"inappropriateFlag":false,"reviewedFlag":false,"autoModerated":false,"published":true,"incentivized":false,"upVotes":0,"downVotes":0,"orderId":null,"dimensions":[],"responses":[],"tags":[],"media":{"photo":[],"video":[],"audio":[]},"user":{"nickName":"John","firstName":null,"lastName":null,"emailAddress":null,"externalId":null,"city":null,"state":null,"country":null,"ageRange":null,"badge":null,"shopperProfiles":[]},"reviewedDate":null,"purchaseDate":null,"dateCreated":"2025-06-12T00:00:00-04:00","customData":[],"incentiveType":null,"campaign":null,"deviceFingerprint":null,"topics":[],"syndication":{"sourceName":"Johnston Murphy","siteUrl":"https://www.johnstonmurphy.com","logoUrl":"https://images.turnto.com/site/syndicationlogos/4378_LH48.png"},"catalogItems":[{"sku":"12128-2502641","title":"Men's Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Plain Toe Dress Shoes","url":"https://www.scheels.com/p/12128-2502641","category":"oxfords-lace-ups","reviewCount":895,"ratingCount":895,"averageRating":4.6,"ratingBreakdown":{"1":34,"2":24,"3":40,"4":107,"5":690},"active":true,"attributes":[]}]},{"id":6861982,"locale":"en_US","rating":4,"title":"Nice and Comfortable","text":"I got these on sale and they feel good and are built well. They are a little wider than I needed but fine over all.","textLength":115,"csFlag":false,"inappropriateFlag":false,"reviewedFlag":false,"autoModerated":false,"published":true,"incentivized":false,"upVotes":0,"downVotes":0,"orderId":null,"dimensions":[],"responses":[],"tags":[],"media":{"photo":[],"video":[],"audio":[]},"user":{"nickName":"Tomas","firstName":null,"lastName":null,"emailAddress":null,"externalId":null,"city":null,"state":null,"country":null,"ageRange":null,"badge":null,"shopperProfiles":[]},"reviewedDate":null,"purchaseDate":null,"dateCreated":"2025-06-11T00:00:00-04:00","customData":[],"incentiveType":null,"campaign":null,"deviceFingerprint":null,"topics":[],"syndication":{"sourceName":"Johnston Murphy","siteUrl":"https://www.johnstonmurphy.com","logoUrl":"https://images.turnto.com/site/syndicationlogos/4378_LH48.png"},"catalogItems":[{"sku":"12128-2502641","title":"Men's Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Plain Toe Dress Shoes","url":"https://www.scheels.com/p/12128-2502641","category":"oxfords-lace-ups","reviewCount":895,"ratingCount":895,"averageRating":4.6,"ratingBreakdown":{"1":34,"2":24,"3":40,"4":107,"5":690},"active":true,"attributes":[]}]},{"id":6648853,"locale":"en_US","rating":5,"title":"Shoes got that \"worn in\"","text":"Shoes got that \"worn in\" look quickly. Great with casual pants!","textLength":63,"csFlag":false,"inappropriateFlag":false,"reviewedFlag":true,"autoModerated":false,"published":true,"incentivized":false,"upVotes":0,"downVotes":0,"orderId":null,"dimensions":[],"responses":[],"tags":[],"media":{"photo":[],"video":[],"audio":[]},"user":{"nickName":"Robert","firstName":null,"lastName":null,"emailAddress":null,"externalId":null,"city":null,"state":null,"country":null,"ageRange":null,"badge":null,"shopperProfiles":[]},"reviewedDate":"2025-06-04T17:21:56-04:00","purchaseDate":null,"dateCreated":"2025-05-26T00:00:00-04:00","customData":[],"incentiveType":null,"campaign":null,"deviceFingerprint":null,"topics":[],"syndication":{"sourceName":"Johnston Murphy","siteUrl":"https://www.johnstonmurphy.com","logoUrl":"https://images.turnto.com/site/syndicationlogos/4378_LH48.png"},"catalogItems":[{"sku":"12128-2502641","title":"Men's Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Plain Toe Dress Shoes","url":"https://www.scheels.com/p/12128-2502641","category":"oxfords-lace-ups","reviewCount":895,"ratingCount":895,"averageRating":4.6,"ratingBreakdown":{"1":34,"2":24,"3":40,"4":107,"5":690},"active":true,"attributes":[]}]},{"id":6645695,"locale":"en_US","rating":1,"title":"Still Love J&M","text":"Not very comfy.","textLength":15,"csFlag":false,"inappropriateFlag":false,"reviewedFlag":false,"autoModerated":false,"published":true,"incentivized":false,"upVotes":0,"downVotes":0,"orderId":null,"dimensions":[],"responses":[],"tags":[],"media":{"photo":[],"video":[],"audio":[]},"user":{"nickName":"Hector","firstName":null,"lastName":null,"emailAddress":null,"externalId":null,"city":null,"state":null,"country":null,"ageRange":null,"badge":null,"shopperProfiles":[]},"reviewedDate":null,"purchaseDate":null,"dateCreated":"2025-05-20T00:00:00-04:00","customData":[],"incentiveType":null,"campaign":null,"deviceFingerprint":null,"topics":[],"syndication":{"sourceName":"Johnston Murphy","siteUrl":"https://www.johnstonmurphy.com","logoUrl":"https://images.turnto.com/site/syndicationlogos/4378_LH48.png"},"catalogItems":[{"sku":"12128-2502641","title":"Men's Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Plain Toe Dress Shoes","url":"https://www.scheels.com/p/12128-2502641","category":"oxfords-lace-ups","reviewCount":895,"ratingCount":895,"averageRating":4.6,"ratingBreakdown":{"1":34,"2":24,"3":40,"4":107,"5":690},"active":true,"attributes":[]}]},{"id":6612193,"locale":"en_US","rating":4,"title":"Great Shoe","text":"A very classy shoe for work and casual attire. Very comfortable to walk long distances in. I wish the sole on the outside could be darker, which is my only knock","textLength":161,"csFlag":false,"inappropriateFlag":false,"reviewedFlag":false,"autoModerated":false,"published":true,"incentivized":false,"upVotes":0,"downVotes":0,"orderId":null,"dimensions":[],"responses":[],"tags":[],"media":{"photo":[],"video":[],"audio":[]},"user":{"nickName":"John","firstName":null,"lastName":null,"emailAddress":null,"externalId":null,"city":null,"state":null,"country":null,"ageRange":null,"badge":null,"shopperProfiles":[]},"reviewedDate":null,"purchaseDate":null,"dateCreated":"2025-05-07T00:00:00-04:00","customData":[],"incentiveType":null,"campaign":null,"deviceFingerprint":null,"topics":[],"syndication":{"sourceName":"Johnston Murphy","siteUrl":"https://www.johnstonmurphy.com","logoUrl":"https://images.turnto.com/site/syndicationlogos/4378_LH48.png"},"catalogItems":[{"sku":"12128-2502641","title":"Men's Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Plain Toe Dress Shoes","url":"https://www.scheels.com/p/12128-2502641","category":"oxfords-lace-ups","reviewCount":895,"ratingCount":895,"averageRating":4.6,"ratingBreakdown":{"1":34,"2":24,"3":40,"4":107,"5":690},"active":true,"attributes":[]}]},{"id":6612192,"locale":"en_US","rating":5,"title":"Great Customer Service","text":"The shoes I ordered did not fit as well as all of my other J&M shoes but I liked the style. I called Customer Service. I was treated very courteously and professionally. The representative listened to my problem and guided me through the return process. I was very impressed. I will continue to be a loyal J&M customer.","textLength":319,"csFlag":false,"inappropriateFlag":false,"reviewedFlag":false,"autoModerated":false,"published":true,"incentivized":false,"upVotes":0,"downVotes":0,"orderId":null,"dimensions":[],"responses":[],"tags":[],"media":{"photo":[],"video":[],"audio":[]},"user":{"nickName":"Stephen","firstName":null,"lastName":null,"emailAddress":null,"externalId":null,"city":null,"state":null,"country":null,"ageRange":null,"badge":null,"shopperProfiles":[]},"reviewedDate":null,"purchaseDate":null,"dateCreated":"2025-05-05T00:00:00-04:00","customData":[],"incentiveType":null,"campaign":null,"deviceFingerprint":null,"topics":[],"syndication":{"sourceName":"Johnston Murphy","siteUrl":"https://www.johnstonmurphy.com","logoUrl":"https://images.turnto.com/site/syndicationlogos/4378_LH48.png"},"catalogItems":[{"sku":"12128-2502641","title":"Men's Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Plain Toe Dress Shoes","url":"https://www.scheels.com/p/12128-2502641","category":"oxfords-lace-ups","reviewCount":895,"ratingCount":895,"averageRating":4.6,"ratingBreakdown":{"1":34,"2":24,"3":40,"4":107,"5":690},"active":true,"attributes":[]}]},{"id":6579198,"locale":"en_US","rating":4,"title":"Nice, Clean Design","text":"Nice shoe with a clean design, fits about a 1/2 size larger than other shoe's I've worn from J&M before. I'm usually a 10. 5, but wear an 11 in these.","textLength":150,"csFlag":false,"inappropriateFlag":false,"reviewedFlag":false,"autoModerated":false,"published":true,"incentivized":false,"upVotes":0,"downVotes":0,"orderId":null,"dimensions":[],"responses":[],"tags":[],"media":{"photo":[],"video":[],"audio":[]},"user":{"nickName":"David","firstName":null,"lastName":null,"emailAddress":null,"externalId":null,"city":null,"state":null,"country":null,"ageRange":null,"badge":null,"shopperProfiles":[]},"reviewedDate":null,"purchaseDate":null,"dateCreated":"2025-05-02T00:00:00-04:00","customData":[],"incentiveType":null,"campaign":null,"deviceFingerprint":null,"topics":[],"syndication":{"sourceName":"Johnston Murphy","siteUrl":"https://www.johnstonmurphy.com","logoUrl":"https://images.turnto.com/site/syndicationlogos/4378_LH48.png"},"catalogItems":[{"sku":"12128-2502641","title":"Men's Johnston & Murphy McGuffey Plain Toe Dress Shoes","url":"https://www.scheels.com/p/12128-2502641","category":"oxfords-lace-ups","reviewCount":895,"ratingCount":895,"averageRating":4.6,"ratingBreakdown":{"1":34,"2":24,"3":40,"4":107,"5":690},"active":true,"attributes":[]}]}],"offset":0,"limit":10,"total":895}"Full Description:\nUpdated textures and styles add interest. <br>Supple oiled full-grain leather or soft matte nubuck and breathable knit. <br>Lightweight strobel construction. <br>Skeletal leather lining. <br>Leather/performance fabric-covered cushioned insole.\n\nFeatures:\n\u003cul>\n\u003cli>Cushioned insole with leather/performance fabric cover\u003c/li>\n\u003cli>Supple full-grain leather or soft matte nubuck upper\u003c/li>\n\u003cli>Breathable knit lining for enhanced comfort\u003c/li>\n\u003cli>Lightweight strobel construction for flexibility\u003c/li>\n\u003cli>Skeletal leather lining for a refined feel\u003c/li>\n\u003cli>Plain toe oxford design for versatile style\u003c/li>\n\u003c/ul>\n\n"